An Amish woman is attacked. She's left for dead. The community remains closed-lipped. Detective Kelly turns to Ettie Smith to ask questions within her secretive community. When an arrest is made, Ettie is convinced the person is innocent, but will the detective believe it? Kelly finally concedes, but with Paula hovering between life and death the pressure is on the detective to find the perpetrator. Can Ettie untangle the web of Paula's complicated life, and solve the crime before another innocent person is attacked, and possibly .... killed?